Personal Tax Learning Path

Taxation of Employee Stock Options: A CPD Course for CPAsStructure the Plan So the Benefit
Is Taxed Like a Capital Gain

The tax result of a stock option turns on the strike price, the type of employer and when the shares are exercised and sold. Learn the rules, the CCPC traps and the alternatives to a standard plan.

1.0h Verifiable CPD Presentation Slides 365 Days of Access
Taxation of Employee Stock Options course banner

The 50% Deduction Depends on How the Plan Was Set Up

The benefit is employment income. Two separate deductions can halve it, and each has its own conditions. A plan that misses one is taxed in full.

Paragraph 110(1)(d)Any Employer
Paragraph 110(1)(d.1)CCPC Only
Shares
Prescribed shares
Any shares
Benefit Taxed
On exercise
On sale
Strike Price
At least FMV at grant
Can be in the money
Arm’s Length
Required
Required
Holding Period
None
2 years
$200,000 Limit
Large employers only
Exempt

A family member of the owner is not at arm’s length, so options granted on the same terms as other employees do not receive CCPC treatment.

You Advise Employers or Employees on Equity Compensation

From designing the plan to reporting the benefit when the shares are finally sold.

Owners of Private Companies

Setting up a plan to attract and keep key people.

Key Employees

Deciding when to exercise, and when to sell.

Public Company Employees

Options taxed on exercise, and the $200,000 limit.

Growth Companies

Equity in place of salary, and the capital gains exemption.

Management Buyouts

Employees acquiring a stake in the business.

Payroll and Finance Teams

Withholding on a benefit with no cash attached.

When You Exercise Changes What You Pay

One employee of a CCPC, granted options at $1 a share. The shares are worth $11 at exercise and $17 on a later sale. Per share:

Exercised Only at the Sale

All Employment Income

Employment benefit
$16
50% deduction
Not available
Taxable per Share$16
Exercised and Held, Company Fails

Tax on Value Never Received

Benefit after deduction
$5
Capital loss on the shares
$11
Taxable per Share$5
Exercised and Held Two Years

Deduction and Exemption Apply

Benefit after deduction
$5
Gain sheltered by the exemption
$6
Taxable per Share$5

After One Hour, You Will Be Able To

  1. Set a strike price and vesting schedule that keep the 50% deduction available.
  2. Calculate the stock option benefit and identify the year it is taxed.
  3. Apply the conditions of each deduction, including the $200,000 limit.
  4. Spot the non-arm’s length trap in an owner-managed business.
  5. Advise on when to exercise and sell, and the risk if the value falls.
  6. Compare freezes, trusts and profit interests with a standard option plan.

What the Seminar Covers

One one-hour recording in five topics, from designing the plan to the structures that replace it.

1
Topic 1

Designing a Stock Option Plan

  • Where stock options fit among employee incentives, and why they are usually the most tax-effective high-value choice.
  • Nominal, fair market value and floating strike prices, and how each affects the deduction.
  • Vesting schedules, and acceleration on death, disability or a liquidity event.
  • The shareholder agreement terms that govern shares once options are exercised.
2
Topic 2

How the Benefit Is Taxed

  • The employment income inclusion and how it is measured.
  • When the benefit is recognized: on exercise for public companies, on sale for CCPCs.
  • The two 50% deductions under paragraphs 110(1)(d) and 110(1)(d.1), and their different conditions.
  • The $200,000 annual limit for options granted after June 30, 2021, and which employers it applies to.
3
Topic 3

Valuation and the Risk of a Decline

  • Minority discounts, vesting conditions and marketability in setting the strike price.
  • Why discounting a public company strike price can cost the deduction.
  • Tax paid on a benefit when the shares later lose their value, and the capital loss that may never be used.
4
Topic 4

CCPC Issues

  • The two-year holding period, and exercising early to start the clock for the capital gains exemption.
  • Exercising and holding against exercising only at a sale.
  • Allowable business investment loss treatment if the company fails, and the AMT that may still arise.
  • Shares redeemed when an employee leaves, buybacks of options, and payroll withholding on the benefit.
5
Topic 5

Alternatives to a Standard Option Plan

  • Freeze structures that issue growth shares to employees for a nominal amount.
  • Trust arrangements with employees as a class of beneficiaries.
  • Profit interest shares that participate only above a threshold value.
  • Co-ownership, partnership and private equity carried interest structures.
Completion

1.0-Hour Verifiable CPD Certificate

Worked Examples from Real Client Situations

Each one shows how a single decision in the plan changes the tax result.

01

The Owner’s Child in the Plan

Same terms as other employees, but no CCPC treatment.

02

A Discounted Strike Price

A small valuation argument that risks the whole deduction.

03

Shares That Become Worthless

Tax already paid on a gain that disappeared.

04

An Employee Who Leaves

Redemption against purchase, and a deemed dividend.

05

Profit Interest Shares on a Sale

Sharing growth above a threshold without an option.

06

Carried Interest in a Fund

Capital gains flowing through a management partnership.

Taught by Practising Tax Specialists

Michael Cadesky

Michael Cadesky

FCPA, FCA, FTIHK, CTA, TEP (Emeritus)

Managing partner at Cadesky Tax and a contributor to the profession since 1980. Past governor of the Canadian Tax Foundation, past chair of STEP Canada and STEP Worldwide, and co-author of 11 books on tax.

Hugh Woolley

Hugh Woolley

CPA, CA, TEP

Independent tax consultant who has taught income tax for over 30 years. Has written courses for CPA Canada and more than 10 papers for the Canadian Tax Foundation and STEP Canada, and wrote butterfly rulings at the CRA’s Rulings Directorate.

Everything Included with Registration

Taxation of Employee Stock Options
$150CAD

365 days of access from registration.

1.0 HourVerifiable CPD
Dec 2023Recorded Live
On DemandStart Immediately
  • 1.0h verifiable CPD certificate
  • Full one-hour seminar recording
  • Presentation slides
  • 365 days of access

Common Questions

How are employee stock options taxed in Canada?

The difference between the value of the shares and the strike price is employment income. If the conditions are met, a deduction of 50% of the benefit is available, so the result approximates capital gains treatment.

When is a stock option benefit taxed for a CCPC employee?

For an arm’s length employee of a Canadian-controlled private corporation, the benefit is deferred until the shares are sold. For other employers, it is included in the year the option is exercised.

What is the $200,000 stock option limit?

For options granted after June 30, 2021, the 50% deduction is limited to $200,000 of options vesting each year. The limit does not apply to CCPCs, or to other employers with consolidated group revenue of $500 million or less.

What happens if the shares lose value after exercise?

The employment benefit is still taxed, but the decline is a capital loss, which can only offset capital gains. For CCPC shares, the loss may qualify as an allowable business investment loss.

Are there alternatives to a stock option plan?

Yes. Freeze structures, trust arrangements, profit interest shares and partnership interests can give employees capital gains treatment without the employment benefit rules.

Can I start right away?

Yes. The seminar was recorded in December 2023 and is available on demand. Register and begin immediately at your own pace.

Does this course provide verifiable CPD?

Yes. You receive a verifiable CPD certificate for 1.0 hour of instructional learning on completion.

What is included and how much does it cost?

Registration is $150 CAD and includes 365 days of access to the full seminar recording and the presentation slides.

Keep Building Your Personal Tax Practice

This course is one of the Personal Tax learning path. These pair well with it.

Design the Plan Before the Options Are Granted

Most stock option problems are set in place on the day the plan is drafted. Know the rules before your client signs.

Register Now · $150 CAD 1.0 hour of verifiable CPD and 365 days of access.
Taxation of Employee Stock Options$150 CAD · 1.0h verifiable CPD
Register · $150