Cadesky Tax Seminars

What Qualifies as a Principal Residence?

Contrary to popular belief, your "principal residence" doesn't have to be your primary home. The exemption can apply to various properties including:

• Family homes
• Cottages
• Ski chalets
• Farms
• Foreign properties (like a Florida condo)
• Mobile homes
• Trailers
• Houseboats
• Leasehold interests in housing units
• Shares in co-operative housing corporations

The key requirement is that the property must be "ordinarily inhabited" by you, your spouse/common-law partner, former spouse/common-law partner, or your child at some point during the year. For seasonal properties like cottages, weekend use can satisfy this requirement.

Understand the Principal Residence Exemption

Cadesky Tax Seminars offers an on-demand 2-hour CPD seminar on the Principal Residence Exemption that provides comprehensive guidance on this complex tax topic. This course qualifies for verifiable CPD credits for CPAs and tax professionals looking to enhance their knowledge of residential property taxation in Canada.

Register for Principal Residence Exemption ➞  

Capital Property Requirement

To qualify for the exemption, the property must be considered "capital property" rather than inventory or property held in an adventure in the nature of trade. This distinction is crucial, as properties purchased with the intention of resale may not qualify.

Since 2023, a new "flipped property rule" applies to residential properties in Canada. If a property is sold within 12 months of purchase, any gain is automatically considered business income (fully taxable) rather than a capital gain, unless a specific life event exception applies.

Land Size Limitations

The principal residence exemption applies to the housing unit and up to ½ hectares (approximately one acre) of land. Land exceeding this limit will only qualify if it's necessary for the use and enjoyment of the housing unit, which is not just desirable but objectively necessary.

This necessity can be established through:

1. Geography of the property (e.g., only one suitable building site far from the road)

2. Legal prohibitions against subdivision (such as minimum lot size requirements)

Claiming the Exemption

Since 2016, you must designate your principal residence on your tax return to claim the exemption. The forms required are:

- Form T2019 for individuals

- Form T1255 for deceased individuals

- Form T1079 for personal trusts

Failure to designate means no exemption, though late designations may be accepted under fairness provisions.

The Calculation: How Much is Exempt?

The exemption is calculated using this formula:

Exempt Portion of Gain = Gain × (1 + # of years as principal residence) ÷ (# of years owned)

The "1+" in the formula (known as the "plus 1 rule") only applies if you were a Canadian resident in the year you acquired the property.

Strategic Planning with Multiple Properties

If you own multiple properties that could qualify as principal residences (like a home and a cottage), strategic planning is essential. The key is to designate the property with the highest gain per year, not necessarily the one with the highest total gain.

For example, if your city home has appreciated steadily over 40 years while your cottage has appreciated significantly over just 8 years, it might be more advantageous to use the exemption for the cottage during the years of overlapping ownership.

Change of Use Considerations

When you convert your principal residence to a rental property, a deemed disposition occurs at fair market value. However, you can elect under subsection 45(2) to avoid this deemed disposition and continue to designate the property as your principal residence for up to four more years (provided no other property is designated).

Similarly, when converting a rental property to a principal residence, you can elect under subsection 45(3) to avoid a deemed disposition, subject to certain conditions.

Special Situations

Foreign Properties

If you sell a foreign property, consider the foreign tax implications before claiming the principal residence exemption. The exemption could eliminate foreign non-business income, potentially wasting foreign tax credits.

Trust Ownership

Since 2017, the principal residence exemption for trusts is limited to:

- Spousal, common-law partner, alter ego, or joint spousal trusts

- Qualifying disability trusts (with additional conditions)

- Trusts for Canadian resident children under 18 where a parent was the settlor and neither parent is alive

U.S. Citizens in Canada

U.S. citizens living in Canada face additional complexities, as the U.S. principal residence exemption is limited to $500,000 (joint) or $250,000 (single), potentially resulting in U.S. tax even when no Canadian tax is payable.

Common Errors to Avoid

1. Designating the wrong property when multiple properties are owned

2. Overlooking the "ordinarily inhabited" requirement for the year of sale

3. Failing to consider excess land limitations

4. Not making the 45(2) election when converting to a rental property

5. Ignoring previous designations of other properties

6. Counting years when you were non-resident

7. Using the "plus 1" rule when the property was purchased as a non-resident

Final Thoughts

The principal residence exemption remains one of the most significant tax benefits available to Canadians, but its complexity requires careful planning and execution. By understanding these rules, you can make informed decisions that maximize your tax savings when selling your home, cottage, or other qualifying properties.